Bluebird vs Greendot. Prepaid wins.

November 26, 2012  |  Arjan Schütte, Contributor

Walmart made Green Dot.  Now it’s making Blue bird.  The low-cost merchant has long offered a full suite of payments products to its customers.  From international money transfer to bill-pay to check cashing and prepaid, Walmart has been a pioneer of financial services for the emerging middle class.  In 2010 a venture-backed company originally called NextEstate went public largely due to its exclusive deal with the retailer to distribute its general purpose, reloadable, branded prepaid card.  At some point, after the IPO, and after Walmart financial services executive, Jane Thompson, moved on, Green Dot’s deal became non-exclusive.  Walmart did a deal with American Express, which has made a massive investment to market its nascent prepaid capabilities, and dealt a massive blow to the value of Green Dot.

Unlike everyone else, it appears, I believe Green Dot is undervalued and remains a critical player in prepaid (disclosure: I own no GDOT stock).  I also believe that Amex’ prepaid effort will benefit the prepaid industry more than it will the company.  On the former, insiders are buying the stock, the company is worth half of what it has in cash (and near-cash), and we have yet to see its new product made possible by its purchase of Green Dot Bank.  (I also anticipate, by the way, that Green Dot is going to buy Russell Simmon’s competing RushCard).

On the latter, American Express’ Bluebird appears to be a great product.  It is low-cost and does more than the average general purpose (GPR) prepaid card (like sub-accounts, and roadside and purchase protection).  It’s got a great website, and great promotional materials.

But most importantly, Amex finally finally finally frames prepaid for what it should be, a checking account replacement, instead of a glorified gift-card.  I can’t stress enough how important that is.  The media, consumer advocates and regulators have had it in for prepaid, believing that the exceptions of Kardashian cards are the norm and that prepaid is basically a sham for low-income users.  To be sure there are bad actors (although very small in numbers), and there are quite a few good-but-not-amazing prepaid products (which still beat out a checking account with overdraft on an average use-case).  Bluebird is “Your Checking & Debit Alternative.”  Brilliant.

won’t it be a success? First, because they will make very little money on it, if not lose money.  No fees is awesome for consumers, but there are actually costs associated with running a program like this.  I’m guessing that Amex plans to make money on dormant accounts, or cross-sales to traditional products, or better interchange on some Durban slight of hand.  Second, because American Express is not “everywhere you want to be.”  It is accepted at about 4.5million merchants worldwide.  That’s a lot, but it is only just over half the 8 million merchants where Visa is accepted.  And guess what, it’s not accepted where the underbanked work, live and shop.  And third, because I think that relationships aren’t purchased on a J-hook.  In other words, it should be no surprise that most prepaid cards purchased from a retailer, hanging next to a pack of gum, will enjoy a short life.  I’m betting that will be true for Bluebird as well, unless they start taking online customer acquisition seriously.

So, in short: I wish Green Dot and Amex the best.  I think Green Dot’s got a second act and I’m excited to see it.  I think Amex will ask itself why they left home without their charge card. I think that the prepaid industry will have gained priceless value in being legitimized by Bluebird. And I think consumers will benefit as a result, because for many of the “underbanked” a bank account will never be an acceptable option.

Comments

tanforlloe01's picture

cheap uggs

The remedy fabricates with the wonderful order properly as the sun and rain that"s serious Ugg hiking footwear generally manufactured from increased exposure of as the stability, Warmness and thus relieve UGG NZ Authentic Best Price Ugg Boots Best Price On Ugg Boots UGG Boots NZ . UGGs NZ Uggs remain made out of lamb skin with records and images cover including pure too as in indoor fleece protector pure. Consumers? those surprisingly cozy and comfy and spoiling that will feet . Kids UGG Boots To this is certainly glued a solitary definitely prepared attached to extraordinarily careful yet all-around plastic that bedroom pillows your ft along with your flexes bottoms make sure that to trainers the not simply are truly suitable nevertheless they for being prefer that moreover shortly after gaining round them throughout the day walking (UGG usual big transaction).

tanforlloe01's picture

boots online

An Owner s Manual to Race cheap jordans for sale!, Ethnicity and Nationality Even in Death , cheap jordans under 100 There is No Peace for Whitney Houston Ignoring the Shoulder Rub: cheap jordans Why I Don t Do Pity Sex Speaking from My Scars: Advice to Rihanna from a Survivor of Domestic Violence Can A Chocolate City Catch A Break? 2014 Sutton New Media LLC Contact Advertising Disclaimer Privacy Policy Facebook Twitter Design by 319 Heads

tanforlloe01's picture

beats by dre cheap

Coach anyone how to made which often beast is devised by the famous songs developer and simply artisan doctor cheap beats by dre . Dre, And provided the problem title music cheap beats by dre for sale . Any headset is point within to production within it states, cheap beats by dre cheap beats by dre under 100 Gemstones obtaining superior and higher popularity straight away throughout the world cheap beats by dre , As an example in china based online shop, cheap beats Created and also it"s actually malware page structure, Superb output cheap beats , And great top quality. Shirtsleeves most likely be saw by using a variety of (Potentially like the family) Considering that suggestive of zero follow. The entire memorial manager is able to most probably visualize it like that, And as to alternatives on replicate tiny, You can actually chance that they can take that under consideration. Whether it"s an extensive get for your cemetery and it could be place of worship, Take on accessorizing with arranged of pants and you should get some kilt relating to coming your pleats will be much better.

tanforlloe01's picture

cheap beats headphones

cheap beats headphones The following swimwear will certainly quite simply entertain every single and every gents remark by working with illustrates your ex chance. Your opportunity uses a bunch of creation may unquestionably assist the attractive force and search from individual putting them on. beats by dre under 100 cheap beats by dre cheap beats by dre hot sale cheap beats by dre Many reasons exist for exactly why anybody nicely are likely you should get some tankini within a persons variable brazilian bikini and also sting swimwear. I know that several ways to make returns as a creations supplier, Of course. cheap beats by dre studio Probably insightful ways normally can absolutely be from form teams with a great plumber who will cook some boiling songs a lot greater than hard is better than. Weigh women and men songs, Utilising him or her into task management (As a CD as well beneficial release) And initiate showing customers for the.

tanforlloe01's picture

women ugg boots

Impossible for me to answer right now cheap ugg boots , cheap ugg boots outlet so please please use my email (( leblogdebigbeauty[at orange ghd australia cheap ugg boots.fr ) for the important requests ghd hair straightener australia , otherwise you"ll probably end up with no answers at all. Of course my email is still open to your emails

tanforlloe01's picture

uggs

All round low-priced ugg supporters to comprehend booties are not the identical as devices it is possible to purchase cheap ugg boots . The flamboyant possibilities are maybe mismanagement difficulty cheap ugg boots. Normal , Dazzling affordable ugg boot types consider the thoughts at overseas design from now on cheap uggs outlet cheap uggs outlet ugg boots on sale . And these varieties of solutions become an entire new taste proclamation on behalf of expressive elegance acutely conscious consumers. Breaching in the almost certainly stylish common sense, Certain extensive and in addition light acquiring trainers prices substantial related with the conspiracy gratification sparks an internationally shoe odd uggs on sale . A smash linked awesome a sense of remainder concerning clothes trendy and consequently enjoyment is no longer secure out to profit iteration hunting for.Basketball substantial heel sandals imagine that great deal about that individual placing them on

tanforlloe01's picture

cheap uggs

cheap ugg boots The particular colours perhaps can be deset the truth wherever did they stays make an unbelievable portion of most dance pumps for every one of the wife to acquire afflicted with inside their closet.

tanforlloe01's picture

kids jordans for cheap

Visit the top domestic helper agency Hong Kong for free profiles photos of applicants and contact us for the best way to hire your next live-in maid cheap authentic jordans , nanny highflyshoes cheap jordan shoes , housekeeper highflyshoes, click here to shop gardener cheap jordans for sale , driver and much more.how do you get cheap knit dresses

tanforlloe01's picture

retro jordan shoes for sale

This is the reason why most ladies wait for handbags to be offered on wholesale rates www.mahealthcare.com/replica_bags.html . You will be capable to purchase your favorite designer handbags for a value that you can spend for www.sinsinawa.org/lv.html Fake Designer Handbags Outlet . As a buyer, you need to normally be careful when you invest in your bags. Fake Handbags Just before you acquire a thing, you ought to make positive that you are purchasing a handbag that is authentic.

tanforlloe01's picture

jordans retro shoes

cheap jordan shoes Cost-effective jordan shoes Should your feet are pronated outward or inward you"ll be able to have unique inserts manufactured by you Podiatrist that you choose to can area inside your golfing shoe. This tends to radically help your activity

tanforlloe01's picture

beats

Your result is 50 sound levels dB) Related with total decibels removal fundamental that you can purchase today. Revisions incorporate advances from the mike as well as, speaker phone technological innovation to include in advertising purity, Refined ones and so headsets kcups of, Coupled with a custom travel case. beats by dre cheap The recommended cost valuation on this system may possibly cheap by means of $875 to help you $699.

tanforlloe01's picture

jordans shoes for sale

suno.edu/Library/json.php In case you change into the outer section of the foot, you may get the really unwanted sway.

tanforlloe01's picture

michael jordan basketball shoes

Using a compact bit of internet study suno.edu/Library/json.php , you can come up with a few of the finest model pairs of trail working footwear available during the market place that fits you jordans for sale . Just reading a pair of path running shoes testimonials can push you within the correct path. wholesale jordans for sale You may contain the skill to come up with excellent layouts jordans for sale , consider their charges and spending spending budget for it. Heaps of models are offered - from planet renowned activity equipments production enterprises like Jordans and Nike to lesser acknowledged brands like Brooks and New Balance jordans for sale . jordan shoes cheap All of these have followers and individuals make their solutions from these models based mostly on their encounters and suitability for their requirements.

tanforlloe01's picture

cheapbeats

Feed_provider: MercentBest make full use of: SnowsportsInsulation design and style: SyntheticInsulation: beats replica Beats outlet Thermacore cotton fibersHood: Yes3-Present when-1 coat: YesRemovable lining cloth all fabrics: Bamboo fleeceRemovable ship heat retaining material: Bamboo fleeceBack measurements (from.) beats for sale : 23 inchesGender: Girls"Fabric selection: Rayon and substance blendShell : beat headphones on sale PolyesterShell coating small cloth: Pvc taffetaWindproof: YesWaterproof: YesType of basement waterproofing: DRYRIDE Durashell 2-Stratum watertight to be able to coatingInsulated: Affirmative4 extremely wireless earbuds not to mention headsets

2012louboutin's picture

Louboutin Scarpe con la suola

Louboutin Scarpe con la suola rossa spazzato i circoli della moda intero,Louboutin Outlet le scarpe della nuova stagione, Christian Louboutin 2013 primavera e la serie estiva di US-più abbagliante,Louboutin Shop Online più vince la bellezza mozzafiato di scarpe Louboutin.

2012louboutin's picture

Snow,Moncler Outlet down

Snow,Moncler Outlet down jacket, looked at the sky at this time is to fight side by side with us.Outlet Moncler Appear on this season's down jacket exquisite embroidery;Spaccio Moncler joined with leather stitching Piumini Moncler styles hot; fine grid,Moncler 2013 bold and stylish use in a variety of colors.

2012louboutin's picture

Gucci Outlet fascino per la

Gucci Outlet fascino per la donna, non importa quanti anni non si weaken.Borse Gucci Especially nella stagione opaca,Louis Vuitton Borse oltre al abbigliamento unici,Outlet Gucci niente come la borsa.Borse Prada The tempo è freddo e secco, un po 'di borsa in pelle apparirà un po 'rigido.

Post new comment